I’m with you on the “All I Ask of You.” We had all Broadway love songs played while people were entering the church and the singer sang “Til There Was You” from the Music Man. I would suggest looking into some of the songs from the musical Aspects of Love.

Here’s the biggest and best list of wedding songs I’ve ever seen:

Wedding Songs

If you are getting married in a church your choices may be limited so you may want to check with the church musicians for suggestions. There are plenty of contemporary Christians songs that are not like the old stuffy hymns.

If the ceremony is someplace other than a church youc an pretty much choose anything you want.

Here are some great sites that may help:

Good luck!

“ill be” by edwin mccain
“when you look me in the eyes” jonas brothers
“shes my everything” keith urban

just a few.